I Hate Decisions Like This...
I usually don't have a problem making decisions. I just go with my gut, and never look back. But, it's different when it involves your kids, and it's a decision that will affect them for the rest of their childhood. I made one of those decisions last week. I decided to hold Cohen back a year in school. It was one of the hardest decisions of my life. I can not tell you how much I have agonized over this decision. It has consumed my thoughts for the past several months. It's one of the those decisions that will affect not only his school life, but almost every other aspect of his life as well...like who his friends will be, and who he'll play sports with, and who he'll date in high school, etc. Those things can make or break an adolescence, so I knew it was important to make the right decision. After weighing the pros & cons of each, and asking his Heavenly Father to help me figure out what would be best for him, I finally came to the conclusion that holding him back was the right thing to do.
My only concern in making this decision was that Cohen may someday hate me for it. What happens in May 2026 when all the kids his age are graduating from high school & he still has a year left? Will he be mad at me? What happens when he graduates from high school in May 2027 & then turns 19 only two months later and basically goes straight from high school to being a missionary? Can a kid who just graduated from high school possibly be ready to take care of himself for two years in places like Bolivia, Russia, or Mexico? It seems like it would be a smoother transition if he moved away to college for a few months first before he moved halfway around the world, doesn't it? Those are the things I worried about. (Yes, I know I'm crazy to worry about things that are 15+ years down the road. But that's what I do! I'm a worrier...and proud of it, thank you very much.) So, someday...because I know the day will come...when Cohen asks me why Mike & I decided to hold him back a year, I'll just pull up this post & let him read the thoughts that went into making this decision.
First of all, Cohen's birthday is July 26th, so he's one of the youngest kids in his class. In fact, I believe he really IS the youngest in his current preschool class. When he walked into his classroom on that first day of school, I noticed that he was about 4-6 inches shorter than all the other kids in his class. I thought, "Wow! I knew Cohen was little, but I didn't realize he was THAT little." I also thought, "These kids look so much older than him! There's no way he's old enough to go to school with them!" I wondered why I hadn't felt this way with Connor & Aiden when they started school. They were as tall as the other kids & they looked just as old as the other kids too. After thinking for a few seconds, the answer was simple...Connor & Aiden both had fall birthdays, so they were almost four-years-old when they started preschool. Cohen had barely turned three only one month earlier. There's a BIG difference between an almost-four-year-old and a barely-three-year-old!
As Cohen has gone through the first half of the school year, I've noticed that he hasn't been picking up on some of the concepts they were learning. When they were learning about colors, I would show him the worksheet that he had done in school earlier that day about the "color of the day" and ask him "What color is this?" He would reply excitedly with "Blue!!!" Unfortunately, it was an apple that was beautifully colored...eh, scribbled...with red crayon. The next day, he would bring home a picture of a sunshine colored a bright yellow. "Cohen, what color is this?" I would ask. "Blue!!!" he would reply again. Everything was blue. I worked and worked and worked with him on colors, but nothing helped. Everything was blue! His brothers understood colors when they were in preschool, why didn't he? I thought maybe he was possibly colorblind or something. There had to be SOME reason why he wasn't learning and understanding his colors. But, when they moved on to shapes, the same thing happened. Every shape was a triangle. We worked and worked on it, but same thing...everything was a triangle. What was wrong? Something HAD to be wrong! But, then I remembered an experience I had had a few years earlier when Aiden was Cohen's same age.
Aiden's birthday is September 7th, which means he missed the school year deadline by six days...SIX DAYS!!! When he was only a week away from turning three, and all his friends were starting preschool, I felt bad for him that he had to wait another year. I heard about a group of moms in my neighborhood that were doing a Joy School for their three-year-olds, rather than sending them to an actual preschool. I asked them if they would mind if Aiden & I joined, even though he was technically in the grade under the rest of the kids. They agreed. One of the moms made up a curriculum of things that kids usually learn during their first year of preschool...letters, numbers through 10, animals, shapes, colors, etc. We decided which moms would teach school on which days, and we were off. When it was my turn to teach the kids, I definitely noticed that the other kids picked up on the concepts much quicker than Aiden did. In fact, in many instances, I could see that things were going right over the top of his head. His barely-three-year-old brain couldn't handle many of the abstract concepts. I really didn't care much though because he was going to be in the grade under all the other kids, so I held him to a different standard.
As I saw Cohen struggling with different concepts, I remembered that experience with Aiden. Aiden was technically in the grade under the kids in his class, so I didn't care that he wasn't reaching the set standard. But I was FORCING Cohen, who was really only a month & a half older than Aiden was when he did Joy School, to reach the same standards as kids that were older than him. His little barely-three-years-old brain wasn't ready for things like this.
It all made sense! That's when I sort of started thinking about holding him back. At first, I was against it. You send your kid to school when they're supposed to go to school...that's just what you do. I didn't want him to be the kid that "got held back." He would catch on eventually & if I had to work extra hard with him, I was willing to do that. But, as time went on, I had some serious anxiety about it. The preschool that my kids go to is very academically-accelerated. They teach the kids how to read in the four-year-old class. By the time the kids are done, many of the kids (like Connor) are reading at a 1st grade benchmark. Other kids (like Aiden) are at almost a 2nd grade benchmark. It is an amazing program, and I love it! But, the thought of Cohen starting that program a little over six months from now made me physically ill! If he wasn't understanding simple things like shapes & colors, how was he going to learn reading in just six months?!? I worried that it would go over the top of his head & he would hate reading because of it. That's when I seriously started thinking about holding him back a year.
So, I started doing research. I talked to a lot of people about it. I talked to his teacher. I talked to the director of the preschool. I talked to the principal at the Elementary School. They all told me that generally summer boys tend to struggle. Their minds develop slower than girls & they have a hard time keeping up with the kids that are older than them. I talked to a friend of mine that is a therapist. He told me that boys have this need to be bigger & stronger & better & smarter than other boys around them. It's their natural need to figure out who the "leader of the pack" is. He said that Cohen would most likely have a much better self-esteem being the oldest in his class, as compared to the youngest. After that, I talked to a lot of moms that had boys with summer birthdays. Many of them had sent their kids to school when it was their time to go, but I also found quite a few that had chosen to hold their boys back...way more than I expected, in fact! I heard pros & cons from both sides, but I must say that I heard way more pros from the moms that had held their summer boys back. Only one of the 9 women I talked to that had held their boys back was unhappy about it (she ended up getting her child tested out of a grade so that he could get back up to where he was originally supposed to be.) The boys who were held back were really excelling. The summer boys that weren't held back were, for the most part, doing okay but had struggles in some areas. That wasn't the case with all of them though, there were some summer boys that were thriving & keeping up with the rest of the kids in the class. So, it really depended on the child. Most of the moms just said to follow my heart. They told me that no one knows Cohen better than me, so I just needed to do what my heart told me to do. By this point, my heart was definitely telling me to hold him back. He just seemed to fit in so much better with the kids that were going to be a year younger than him in school. Academically, physically, socially, emotionally, etc...he just seemed to be on the same level as them. It just felt right.
Mike & I prayed about it. Many times in my life, when I have had a huge decision to make, I got an extremely strong answer...almost like I heard a voice in my head telling me what to do (Yes, you can make fun of me for "hearing voices." Haha!) Deciding to marry Mike was one of those moments. Deciding to leave the TV business & move back to SLC to be a stay-at-home mom was one of those moments. (By the way, if you haven't heard that story before, have me tell it to you. It is a really amazing story that proves that God has His hand in all things.) This time however...wasn't one of those moments. I didn't get a really strong answer or hear a voice telling me what to do. But, every time I thought about pushing Cohen along, I got a horrible pit in my stomach. Every time I thought about holding him back, I got a very calm, relaxed feeling. That was my answer. He was supposed to be held back a year.
So, when I went to preschool registration last week, I signed him up to repeat the three-year-old class. It felt so great! I know that if I had checked the four-year-old box instead of the three-year-old box, it would have felt horrible & totally wrong. This is going to be such a good thing for him! Now I just hope he doesn't hate me for it. Go Class of '27! --Lindsay
p.s. On a side note, Cohen is my kid that has some serious natural ability at sports. He has always loved to play sports & is actually better at some sports than his brothers who are three and six years older than him. I'm not even kidding! If he continues to show natural abilities in sports, and wants to play on a team when he's in Jr. High & High School, I want him to have a fighting chance. Now that he won't be one of the youngest & smallest in his grade, he may actually stand a chance of making it. Just something we thought of after the fact.






12 comments:
Sounds like you made the right decision. I worry about things 15 down the road too!! Jay was the youngest in his class and hated it. He was fine academically but was really small.
He also didn't like that he had to wait so long after high school to go on his mission while all his other friends were gone.
Lindsay, I'm so glad I read your post. It helps me understand what my preschool parents go through. I know I've commented before on your FB that we sent our summer birthday son (July 4th) to kindergarten as scheduled, and he struggled the whole year. It wasn't that he wasn't intelligent enough, but he lacked maturity. So the next year they basically forced him to go to a class called "Pre-First". We did it reluctantly but it was for the best. He never really minded that he was behind the other kids his age (except that his church friends of the same age graduated the year before him). He was able to drive earlier than the kids in his class and he liked that. And yes, he was one of those kids who graduated June 20th and left on his mission July 9th. He did just fine. I think you are doing the right thing for Cohen. You have put much energy, prayer and discussion into this decision. Cohen is lucky to have such concerned parents! Love, Pat Bahr (partypatt)
From what I'm seeing in our ward, the boys are waiting so long after graduating to go on their missions that they are getting sidetracked and moving on with life and wanting to skip the mission. I personally think it's a good thing to go ASAP after high school.
Roman is a summer birthday too but we decided to send him. He was reading before Kindergarten, he's both big and tall so he's not smaller than the other kids and he's always done really well in school... for him it would have been a big mistake to hold him back and it was obvious. Our only issue has been maturity and he's done fairly well at adapting (I think being the oldest kid made a difference too). You have to do what's best for your kid, and if you pray and do your research... you know what that is.
Being a parent is hard, especially when it comes to making those BIG decisions about their lives. I told you about Tait's situation. It was a hard choice to make, but it's turned out to be the best choice I've ever made. I only wish I would have done it sooner (like when he was Cohen's age) like I was prompted to do a few times before but was too scared.
All we can do is rely on the guidance of our Heavenly Father, who knows our children better than we do, and rely on our own instincts as parents and then not just hope for, but expect the best.
I've learned that life and education are not a competition. Instead of always viewing things according to age and grade level, I need to sometimes put all those things aside and determine what is best for my child at that time in his life, which may not be exactly the same as another child the same age.
One more thing...
If you start to second-guess your choice, I know from experience that it's HELL to watch your child's self-esteem be diminished and watch him begin to believe he's stupid because day after day he just doesn't "get it." I would much rather live with him possibly wishing he could have graduated a year sooner, than go through the rest of his school career believing he's dumb.
You are a great mom! My sister-in-law did the same thing for her summer boy. And he does great. I'm glad you listened! The spirit sometimes doesn't give us as strong of an answer as we would like, even in huge major decisions. He often just whispers and we have to listen very closely.
I so wish I could go back in time and hold my son back. I think it does help self esteem and especially with boys, it gives them more of an upper hand on the maturity curve. Hope it works out to be a great thing!
Your story makes me think of katelyn! She just turned 3 yesterday and everything is the color blue, everything is a circle, she doesn't catch on as fast as Allyson did at this age. I also sent Allyson to a preschool that's pretty tough academically and she started when she was 3 years and 3 months old and I felt like she was ready for it. She already knew some of her letters, she knew the basic shapes and basic colors, how to count to 10 ... And she knew it all before she started. It shocks me to think that katelyn is 3 years old because Allyson was so much further along at this age. I still have difficulty understanding what katelyn says a lot of the time and people outside of our family can almost never understand what she's saying. I don't feel like she's ready for preschool, but it worries me to not put her in preschool because maybe doing 2 years of preschool could help her? What if we dont so 2 years of preschool and she ends up not being ready for kindergarten and we hold her back? I don't know what I'll end up doing, but it IS difficult to decide things like this because like you said - it really does affect the rest of their lives. I'm glad you figured it all out and feel comfortable with your decision to hold him back. That's really the best that you can do. I doubt he'll hate you for it, knowing that you put as much consideration into it as you did. You're a good mom! :)
Sounds like you made the best decision! I can imagine how hard of a decision that would be to make, but it sounds like it's definitely the right thing for sweet Cohey. Love you Coconut!
Great post Lindsey! These decisions are so hard. I am actually debating having Jake do Kindergarten again...not sure, but his Bday is May 21st, so he is one of the youngest in his class. I just want him to enjoy school/learning and I know he won't if it is constantly a struggle for him. We are waiting to see at the end of the school year, but just know that I feel your pain. I struggle with this question too. So glad you have your answer for your sweet little guy. :)
I'm still clueless in the whole kids-in-school thing. Addie was born the same week as Cohen, so she'd be in the same school year. With how timid she is, I've been wondering how she'll do. I didn't even really know you could hold them back a year, but that makes lots of sense. Hmm...something to look into, I guess
I am so glsd to hear of your decision!!! Being a kindergarten teacher I see this hppen often BUT most times mom just want their child to be in school. You are doing the best service to your boys by holding them back that year! You will find it will be worth it in the end and NO they will not hate you. I have never heard a parent say, "Oh I should have just sent them." Instead I hear, "I am so glad I did not start them when I could have." Thank you for giving it so much thought and making the choice you did!
Post a Comment